Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up

Official benefits: How NHL teams have been drawing and taking penalties since the lockout

Tuomo Ruutu, Joe Corvo, Bryan Rodney, Ray Whitney, Niklas Backstrom

Carolina Hurricanes’ Tuomo Ruutu (15), Joe Corvo (77) and Bryan Rodney (33) congratulate Ray Whitney (13) on his power-play goal in front of Minnesota Wild goalie Niklas Backstrom, left, during the second period of an NHL hockey game in Raleigh, N.C., Sunday, Nov. 15, 2009. The Hurricanes won 5-4 in a shootout. (AP Photo/Karl B DeBlaker)

AP

Last night’s foray into the land of non-traditional stats focused on special teams, power play and penalty kill plus minus totals for the 2010-11 season, but perhaps to little surprise, it sparked a deeper journey down the numerical rabbit hole.

The Special Teams Plus/Minus post featured a bonus stat that I called “Special Teams Opportunity Plus/Minus.” Much like the others, this stat is resoundingly simple: you just subtract the power play opportunities a team receives minus the times that team goes shorthanded.

It seems like an interesting stat for the 2010-11 season, but even an 82-game campaign can bring about some anomalies. One could imagine that at least a small set of fans for all 30 NHL teams feel like officials are “out to get them” so I felt the need to take the experiment a little further.

With that in mind, I decided to see which teams have benefited the most (or suffered the greatest) from officials’ calls by combining the opportunity plus/minus totals from every post-lockout season. Naturally, it’s important to note that this list doesn’t necessarily prove that a team has a preferential relationship (especially considering how NHL teams’ schemes vary in aggressiveness). It’s just interesting food for thought - and yes - maybe a little fuel for the fire.

Special Teams Opportunities +/- since the lockout

TeamTotal2010-112009-102008-092007-082006-072005-06
CAR362741273655286
SJS29615-18546480101
NJD206-434-1769691
LAK158163-2583152
DAL137294024050-6
BUF122-212922332138
TBL11034-10-62-166995
DET911402634-100
MIN87-1633783817
TOR79512722-9-175
PHX51-7-3517-2528
COL39-4970342126
NSH28-328-202321-21
PIT26-13-1132144-38
NYR2033-1717276-46
ATL64-4-9-381637
EDM-29-17-416-22-97
VAN-39-165-141-2914
STL-480-35-6-25-3351
CGY-7236-379-37-13-30
OTT-101-37-28-7-52914
BOS-1040-77-13-30-61
MTL-110-37-50432-41-18
CHI-145222933-20-79-130
WSH-158-36-3-50-3-6-60
CBJ-172-13-26-24-22-15-72
PHI-181-18-18-77-3-44-21
NYI-199-86-41-45-85-26
ANA-209-20-24-76-47-12-30
FLA-251022-3-61-106-103

***

Atlanta Thrashers v Florida Panthers

SUNRISE, FL - JANUARY 5: Bryan McCabe #24 of the Florida Panthers discusses a call with referee Frederick L’Ecuyer #17 and referee Marc Joannette #25 in the third period against the Atlanta Thrashers on January 5, 2011 at the BankAtlantic Center in Sunrise, Florida. The Thrashers defeated the Panthers 3-2. (Photo by Joel Auerbach/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Bryan McCabe;Frederick L’Ecuyer;Marc Joannette

Joel Auerbach

As it turns out, the Hurricanes’ 2010-11 lead in this category was far from a fluke. Now, before you hatch too many conspiracy theories, it’s important to note that Carolina is a team that is known for pushing the pace of play. That being said, two playoff berths since the lockout seems like an underachievement when you consider their steady stream of advantages.

Update: The Panthers had the worst relationship, but the most interesting/disturbing part is that most of the damage was done in the first two seasons (-209 disparity between 05-06 and 06-07).

The Maple Leafs have their own drought to worry about, but they came in at No. 10 with 79 more calls going their way. Sidney Crosby haters might be disappointed to see that the Penguins are almost exactly in the middle of the pack at 14th with +26.

Want to see the sheer number of power plays and penalty kills for all 30 NHL teams? Here it is. (This list is sorted by most power play opportunities received.)

TeamTotal PPTotal PK
CAR24502088
PIT23332307
LAK23092151
VAN22802319
DAL22642127
SJS22421946
PHX22272176
TOR22162137
ATL22132207
DET22112120
BUF22002078
CBJ21762348
CGY21752247
STL21642212
EDM21612190
TBL21602050
WSH21572315
NYR21532133
NSH21512123
MTL21402250
PHI21332314
ANA21332342
OTT21072208
MIN21002013
CHI20802225
COL20752036
NYI20562255
BOS19922096
FLA19452196
NJD19431737

***

In case you’re wondering, the Blue Jackets took the most penalties (2,348) followed by the Ducks (2,342). Meanwhile, the Devils were whistled the least (1,737) by quite a margin; the Sharks were a distant second with 1,946. There probably weren’t many people out there holding onto this thought anyway, but those numbers should show that New Jersey could adapt/maintain their reputation as a responsible defensive team despite the post-lockout rule changes.

(Want even more specifics? Click here for a spreadsheet that includes all the yearly numbers.)
***

Again, I want to emphasize that this post isn’t meant to “prove” that some teams get preferential treatment while others get the short end of the stick. Feel free to argue for or against such possibilities in the comments, though. (Something tells me Red Wings fans might be a little bummed out to see that Detroit came in at +91, even if this post won’t stop their loudest factions from concocting elaborate conspiracy theories anyway.)