Tag: Coyotes sale

Doug Creighton, Peter McCullough

Winnipeg mayor doubts the Coyotes will move; Thrashers might relocate there instead


Many people in the hockey world wondered if the Coyotes played their final game in Phoenix when the Detroit Red Wings completed their first round sweep. In fact, the very premise prompted a steady stream of cruel jokes on Twitter.

While relocation is still a legitimate possibility amid the troubling Coyotes sale situation, it doesn’t take an expert to notice that the NHL and City of Glendale are doing the best they can to avoid relocation. Their best efforts might not overcome the threat of a lawsuit by the Goldwater Institute, but the bottom line is that more money might be lost if the Coyotes leave than if they stay.

(That’s a sad sentence, but sometimes sporting reality is pretty depressing.)

There’s at least one rather significant party who thinks that the Coyotes will stay put. That would be Winnipeg mayor Sam Katz, who believes that the hockey-hungry city should look for a different team to bring the NHL back to the ‘Peg. Here are his comments via the Winnipeg Sun.

“Do I believe the Coyotes are coming to Winnipeg? My answer would be no,” Katz said. “I believe the Coyotes will stay in Phoenix. I happen to know some of the commitments that were made when they went there, and there were commitments that, if they were not fulfilled, there could easily be a lawsuit.”

If you believe Katz, then the Coyotes sale faces a lose-lose scenario: a possible lawsuit whether they stay or go. Both the NHL and Goldwater Institute’s people seemed confused by the claims Katz made about the possibility of a lawsuit if the Coyotes relocate, though.

NHL Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly said he didn’t know what commitments Katz might be talking about.

“I can’t say that I know what he is referring to,” Daly said via e-mail Wednesday.

Nick Dranias, constitutional policy director for the Phoenix-based Goldwater Institute, a taxpayer watchdog group trying to block the Coyotes’ sale to would-be buyer Matthew Hulsizer, was equally baffled by Katz’s claim.

“It doesn’t make any sense to me,” Dranias said. “If he’s talking about obligations or agreements that were reached before the Hulsizer deal, that would have come out during bankruptcy.”

Even if Katz was incorrect in his claims that a lawsuit would be a possibility, his comments underscore the notion that the Atlanta Thrashers might be a strong Plan B for Winnipeg. Gary Lawless of the Winnipeg Free Press claims that the Atlanta Spirit ownership group is desperate to sell the Thrashers after failing to do so with a local group for years. (Regardless of former MLB pitcher Tom Glavine’s best efforts, it seems.)

Despite some reasonable possible other cities for relocation (Kansas City’s cushy arena deal comes to mind), Lawless writes that it would be difficult for the Thrashers to relocate to any other market than Winnipeg with such a short window between the sale and the start of the 2011-12 season in October.

In other words, all signs point to Winnipeg being the only relocation option for both the Thrashers and Coyotes. So the Atlanta Spirit must wait and see if the Coyotes remain in Arizona before they can make their move.

Keep in mind all of this talk is based on speculation from unnamed sources, so there might be a few factors that are a bit based on conjecture rather than facts. Either way, the fate of two troubled franchises – not to mention the puck-based future for one former NHL city – hangs in the balance over the next weeks/months, so we’ll keep you informed as this messy picture begins to come into focus.

Atlanta Spirit hopes to avoid moving Thrashers in sale, still speaking with two interested parties


When we last checked in on the Atlanta Thrashers sale situation, a heightened “sense of urgency” from owners The Atlanta Spirit spurred conversations with three potential owners hoping to keep the team in Georgia. In many ways, the Thrashers sale has slipped under the radar – and been put on hold – because of the Phoenix Coyotes’ conundrum. Yet much like the Coyotes, the Thrashers must face the very real possibility of relocation.

That’s not to say that relocation is an absolute certainty, though. The Canadian Press passes along word that Thrashers owners continue to discuss the possibility of selling the team only to people who would keep the franchise in Atlanta.

While the number of groups decreased from three to two, the notion that there’s at least some activity provides a slight reason for optimism for Atlanta-area hockey fans. Despite the fact that the Atlanta Spirit are encumbered by the fact that they own two struggling professional sports franchises – they also run the NBA’s Atlanta Hawks – negotiations have only involved the Thrashers, so the deal shouldn’t be excessively complicated.

That being said, having some unnamed interested parties dipping their toes in the water is one thing, but getting a deal done is a whole other ballgame. Especially regarding a team that still draws only tepid attention from sports fans, as the Thrashers boast the third-worst attendance averages in the NHL (according to the Canadian Press).

Ownership group member Michael Gearon, Jr. had an interesting response when he was asked when the group might give up on its goal of selling only to an owner who would keep the team in Atlanta.

Asked last month when he might give up on finding a new ownership for the Thrashers to remain in Atlanta and turn his search to those wishing to move the team, Gearon said “That’s a Gary Bettman question.”

Bettman, the NHL commissioner, has said he wants the team to remain in Atlanta. Bettman said last month any problems with the Thrashers “ultimately will have to be dealt with.”

Gearon and Levenson have said they are willing to retain minority shares of the Thrashers or sell all their interests in the team.

When it comes to the fate of both the Thrashers and Coyotes franchises, it all really might come down to how Bettman answers such questions. The NHL keeps delaying such choices – with reason – but eventually they will have to bite the bullet and make a decision that will have a large impact on the makeup of the league.