Tag: Best and Worst Sweaters of All Time

Wayne Gretzky - Burger King sweater

Find all of our “Best and worst sweaters of all-time” posts right here


If you’ve been missing out on my posts on the “best and worst sweaters of all-time” I’m here to round them up like a sheepdog and keep them together so you can read up on everything at any time. If you think we haven’t done your team at all, keep your pants on it’s here.

Now sit back, relax, and enjoy the fun.

Monday:  Boston BruinsVancouver CanucksNew Jersey DevilsAnaheim DucksSt. Louis BluesFlorida Panthers

Tuesday:  Chicago BlackhawksBuffalo SabresNew York IslandersMinnesota WildCarolina HurricanesPhoenix Coyotes

Wednesday:  Philadelphia FlyersDetroit Red WingsOttawa SenatorsEdmonton OilersTampa Bay LightningLos Angeles Kings

Thursday: San Jose Sharks, New York Rangers, Toronto Maple Leafs, Nashville Predators, Winnipeg Jets, Colorado Avalanche

Friday: Washington Capitals, Montreal Canadiens, Pittsburgh Penguins, Columbus Blue Jackets, Dallas Stars, Calgary Flames

(Photo: The Royal Half)

Best and worst sweaters of all-time: Calgary Flames

Alex Tanguay, Jarome Iginla

For our final team of the “Best and worst sweaters of all-time” series we head to the great  white north of Calgary where the Flames may not have originated there, but they’ve adopted a look and a name and made it their own.

Best: Perhaps the best sign of the greatness of a single sweater is when it’s brought back from the dead for special occasions and then ultimately becomes the team’s new third jersey. Such is the case for the best Flames sweater of all-time, their original road sweater when the team moved to Calgary. It’s red and, perhaps for some, eye aggravatingly so. With the yellow and white stripes around the sleeves and waist and the letter “C” on fire for the logo it’s got a single beauty all its own.

Seeing the likes of Joe Nieuwendyk, Al MacInnis, Theo Fleury, and Lanny McDonald all sport this look when the team won the 1989 Stanley Cup helped make it even more legendary than it is, but it’s never a bad thing to see the old look brought back so current Flames legend Jarome Iginla can get some glory out of it as well.

Worst: I honestly debated over which of two sweaters the Flames have worn in their history are their absolute worst. While one was a poorly striped modernized version of their old home and away set, I had to lean on the team’s original third sweater as their worst. Going from a bright red sweater to a black one with a new and bizarre horse head logo on the front is one that still makes me shake my head. The Flames’ flaming letter “C” is an incredibly easy and familiar logo, adopting a new look that takes Calgary’s pride in being a rodeo town and putting a flame-breathing horse on the front is just so strange.

I’m not sure if it’s so bad honestly, but with how the team and the city rally around the color red, jumping on the bandwagon for a black alternate was just predictable and ultimately lame. At least the horse head got to live on a little while longer as the shoulder patch on a newer and updated version of the Flames’ uniform.

Sherman’s march to Canada?: Calgary wasn’t a town that had anything to do with fire, but the team moved to Canada from Atlanta. The Flames name came about thanks to General Sherman burning the city down during the Civil War. Much like the Utah Jazz and Los Angeles Lakers, the team nickname has absolutely nothing at all to do with its current home city. Their look in Atlanta, however, was a thing of beauty and one the team was easily able to recreate for being in Calgary. The “flaming A” of Atlanta soon became part of the Flames uniforms as the “A” on the sweaters of team alternate captains.

Assessment: The Flames’ current sweaters are fantastic. The bold flaming “C” adorns all three of their sweaters, and with the flags of Alberta and Canada being on the shoulders of both the home and away sweaters, it’s a proud way for the Flames to stake a claim on their Canadian home. Using the throwback sweater from the 80s as their third is a great touch for the team, but they can’t go wrong with either of their standard sweaters. It’s a stellar look for a team with a proud fan base.

Best and worst sweaters of all-time: Dallas Stars

Brenden Morrow

All right, listen… Not all sweaters can be big winners and remembered forever. The Stars have a nice look to what they’ve got and throughout their history in Dallas they’ve done well embracing the black and green. Unfortunately, they’ve got a much better looking past to contend with among NHL fans outside of Dallas.

Instead of picking one side or the other here to suck up to, I’ll make sure to tick everyone off in some way. Here’s to hoping that Brenden Morrow, Steve Ott, or Neal Broten don’t show up at my door and punch me in the gut.

Best: I’m going to do my best to not pick a Minnesota North Stars sweater here because those days are over. With that stipulation in the way, I’m going to side with their current road sweaters that have “DALLAS” emblazoned across the front with the number on the front of the sweater with it. This sweater in particular started as their alternate sweater, but the look was so good already on their home blacksweater, they had to double their pleasure by putting it on the white as well.

It’s a look that goes against the grain for most NHL sweaters and it often reminds fans a bit too much of the NFL. The crazy part here, it’s a good look. It’s clean, has the Stars logo on the shoulders, and looks seamless. Black, green, and gold are the main colors for the team, but the white sweaters pop with ferocity.

Worst: When you create an alternate sweater that instead of making fans and curious on-lookers think of constellations and the heavens the way it was supposed to, makes them think of cows and female reproductive organs, you’ve failed. The “mooterus” sweater is one that rather than being a hockey sweater is an awkward test of human psychology; like an ink blot test that everyone calls out for being “fallopian tubes” instead of “cattle constellation.” It’s awkward, it’s ugly, it makes everyone squirm in their seats because they’re thinking of seventh grade health class.

Old-timey favorite: All right, now it’s time to talk North Stars. Perhaps the saddest part about Norm Green screwing over the fans in Minnesota when he moved the team to Dallas is that we were forced to lose the Minnesota North Stars sweater. With the perfect logo, the fun color scheme, and a look that lives on to this day as a popular one for NHL fans, it’s one I’m still sad isn’t around on the ice night in and night out. It’s one of those perfect sweaters from the 70s and 80s that everyone can say that they love. Much like the Whalers and Nordiques, when the North Stars moved away part of hockey’s heart went with it.

Assessment: The Stars’ current sweaters are great. They’re boring, but they’re great. The home black sweater is just as good as the road white and while the logo isn’t the biggest part of either. While the logo lives on in their white alternate sweater (one that features their great secondary logo on the shoulders as well) the Stars just don’t have that sort of iconic look to them even in spite of winning the Stanley Cup in 1999. I’m sure fans in Dallas will disagree with me on this and hate that the North Stars are even mentioned here, but you’re going to have to deal with it.

Best and worst sweaters of all-time: Columbus Blue Jackets

Rick Nash

The Blue Jackets have proven since they started playing in 2000 that getting a look on the ice is a hard thing to do. From insect mascots, stars on the uniform, to oddly phallic new mascots the Blue Jackets have had a hard time with their identity. Here’s to hoping that by embracing the cannon they can latch onto something that will move them forward.

Best: It’s time for me to eat some crow. When the Blue Jackets first unleashed their newest third sweater on the world, I wrote about it here proclaiming it to be too old fashioned, uninspired, and just blah. Just like many things I don’t think about before mouthing off on, I was wrong. The Jackets’ third is an old time lookalike that makes sense for a team that’s trying to pay homage to the Union Army in the Civil War. There are no over-the-top green bugs in a Civil War getup, the Ohio flag isn’t the logo, and the cuffs on the sweater don’t have stars. It’s just a cannon and the team name and a great look.

Worst: Let’s dial it back to the Jackets’ inaugural season. Their team name is all about paying homage to the Civil War and to do that they introduce… A green insect as the mascot. But that’s OK, he’s wearing the Union Army uniform and they made the sweater have a ribbon-like logo on the crest with stars on the cuffs. Whether it was their home or away sweater it was just a confusing look. Good lord, talk about trying too hard to hammer home a theme. Fast forward to the RBK Edge re-design and the bug and the star cuffs are gone. Lots of teams got their look down the right way right off the bat. The Blue Jackets cannot be considered among those teams.

Americana gone wrong: The Winnipeg Jets took some grief for introducing a team logo that was deemed by critics to be “too militaristic” and even “too Canadian,” but the Blue Jackets took the hometown American thing just about as far, just without the modern military influences. With a red, white, and blue color scheme it’s tough to avoid being so seemingly jingoistic, but given the references to the Civil War and the fact they shoot off a cannon at the games, you could say that the Blue Jackets are the most American-themed hockey team since… Well, the New York Americans. Hopefully the Jets’ management takes note what can happen when you get the whole look of the team wrong when it comes to sweater designs by looking at how the Blue Jackets did it when they started in 2000.

Assessment: The Jackets current home and away uniforms are bland by comparison to their third sweater. The Ohio flag-themed logo with the rather dull design of the sweaters when compared to the simple goodness of the third leaves us feeling empty. After all, when your team is named the way it is it can be tough to find a great look. Here’s to hoping they’ll take the third sweater inspiration and run with it for a future re-design.

Best and worst sweaters of all-time: Pittsburgh Penguins

Mario Lemieux

Best: The Penguins have a long history of different looks to their sweaters, but they became legendary when Mario Lemieux, Jaromir Jagr, and Ron Francis led the Penguins to back-to-back Stanley Cups in the early 90s. The black and gold look that’s synonymous with Pittsburgh sports teams was it for the Penguins and that coupled with the skating penguin logo gave the Pens an unrivaled look. Having a team loaded with talent helped make it look even better, but their road sweaters were a great look made even better that they looked like the classic movie villains rolling into town in all black to beat your home-standing favorites.

Worst: It started out as a third jersey (shocking!) for two seasons and ended up being their road sweater for another five. With the newer Pens logo it had some sort of color band effect on it that perhaps was meant to make it look like the logo was in motion. Instead it looked like the logo was leaving behind skid marks. What helped make the sweater look even dumber was that the design on each sleeve. If you can’t even get the sleeves to match and it looks like someone dragged the sweater through a litter box, perhaps it’s not such a great design.

Old-timey favorite: While the Pens have one old fashioned design that they wore in the 2008 Winter Classic and it became their third sweater, I’m more of a fan of their original look. Those sweaters they broke out with during the inaugural 1967 season were sky blue, black, and white and had “PITTSBURGH” in script going down diagonally on the front of the sweater. The lettering and numbers were like that you see on Rangers sweaters and that style looked damn fine. The lace-up collars are a great touch as well. Sure there’s no penguin to be seen on the sweater at all, but for an old time hockey sweater it was a beauty.

Assessment: The Penguins’ current sweater arrangement is a new twist on an old favorite. The skating penguin on the front with a black and gold color scheme on a simple looking sweater is fantastic. Bringing the skating penguin back was such a smart move because it got new fans to identify better with the teams from the 70s, 80s, and 90s. After all, if you’re going to have a lot of new fans getting them to appreciate the team’s history can be difficult.

Adding in the old timey sky blue third and you’ve got a great collection of team sweaters for fans to choose from.  Having Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Jordan Staal to choose from, the Penguins have plenty of jersey sales to back up their look. Of the modern batch of sweaters, the Penguins are amongst the best in the league.