This is part of Canadiens day at PHT …
Here’s an unsolicited opinion: a good backup goalie is often underrated.
Yes, getting a quality Plan B is easier said than done – goalies are an unpredictable lot – but it’s simple to see when it pays off.
(There are plenty of examples, but Matt Murray winning a Stanley Cup for the Pittsburgh Penguins is the shiniest one.)
Even if injuries aren’t a big issue, a No. 2 goalie is a pretty safe bet to play 20 games for a given team. In that regard, Al Montoya could be a significant upgrade over Mike Condon, and that could be important.
In 2015-16, no goalie played 70 regular season games. Jonathan Quick was the workhorse of the NHL with 68, while only 10 played at least 60. So, more than two-thirds of last season’s teams needed at least 24 games from their lesser-paid goalies.
Even in Carey Price‘s dominant 2014-15 campaign, he played 66 games while Dustin Tokarski was in net for 17.
Let’s ponder the outlook for a variety of scenarios as Price hopes to rebound from injury:
If Price resumes Vezina-caliber form
As PHT notes, Price seems confident that he’s at 100 percent.
That’s great … but what else is he going to say? Knee injuries can beguile just about any athlete.
He does admit that he’s getting up there in age a bit – relative to the sport, mind you – at 29. Earlier this summer, the Hockey News went over Montreal’s plan to scale Price’s workload a bit, injured or not.
So, even in a dream scenario, Montoya and/or Condon will still see plenty of reps.
If Price falters
The Canadiens are expected to live or die by Price. Let’s not kid ourselves.
The leash might not be very long for Michel Therrien if Price really falls on his face, however. A Condon-led Habs team stumbled terribly, but what might we see from Montoya being thrust into the spotlight for performance reasons?
- With a .909 career save percentage, Montoya’s experienced his stumbles in the NHL. Montreal has to hope he follows more of the path from strong showings in 2013-14 (13-8-3, .920 save percentage with Winnipeg) and 2015-16 (12-7-3, .919 save percentage with Florida).
Long story short, there were flashes of the brilliance you’d expect from a guy who went sixth overall in 2004.
- The good news is that he’s accustomed to a fairly heavy backup duty. He set a career-high with 31 games played and 26 starts with the Islanders in 2011-12. Including that season, he’s enjoyed 20+ appearances in five of his last six seasons.
- The bad news is that he hasn’t ever even carried half of a season’s workload so …
Yes, a Price re-injury would be disastrous
Montoya hasn’t been “the guy” before, certainly not in a pressure-cooker like Montreal. Condon’s opportunity didn’t go especially well.
One can understand ownership giving Therrien and GM Marc Bergevin something of a “Price pass” after 2015-16, but would there be the same level of acceptance if they couldn’t thrive without their star goalie again? You’d have to ask about lessons learned.
Long story short, Montoya matters to Montreal. The Canadiens just have to hope that he doesn’t matter too much.