Roberto Luongo

Now they’re comparing Luongo to Nowitzki


A week ago, we compared Canucks goalie Roberto Luongo to Donovan McNabb, the former Philadelphia Eagles quarterback who came close to leading his team to a championship but could never quite get over the hump.

If that comparison was depressing for Canucks fans (or uplifting for non-Canucks fans), Vancouver Province columnist Tony Gallagher is thinking of another professional athlete whose story had a much happier ending than McNabb’s in Philadelphia.

As Roberto Luongo listens to the general howl around him he should look across to the NBA and the career of Dirk Nowitzki for fuel to propel him forward.

And those who look at the evidence to date and feel that Luongo just doesn’t have a championship in him had better be prepared to dine on those words if he ever does pull it off. Because that’s what Nowitzki was able to do for the Dallas Mavericks this spring, the parallels in the careers of these two athletes absolutely breathtaking.

I’m not sure if I’d use the word breathtaking (mostly because I associate it with the ugly baby in Seinfeld), but as Gallagher points out, the similarities are indeed compelling.

Both have been considered outstanding players with great regular seasons but too fragile mentally to get it done in the crucible of the playoffs. Prior to this past NBA final, both players had reached the finals in their respective leagues and in that final both teams led by their respective stars Luongo and Nowitzki had gone out to 2-0 leads in that final (and here we refer to the ’06 NBA final between Dallas and Miami). Both teams were even in good shape in game three on the road, the Mavs with a double-digit lead, the Canucks having survived Aaron Rome’s major and the Bruins initial thrust to get out of period one scoreless.

Both teams and both players melted down and eventually lost their respective series under circumstances that seemed to have an odd officiating twist.

And you wonder why Canucks fans are always saying Gary Bettman is out to get their team. Much of it is media driven. But we won’t get into that now.

Comparing one athlete to another can be a useful exercise. In this case, it serves to illustrate the fact we can’t predict the future. In Philadelphia, there were people who said McNabb would never get it done, and they were right. In Dallas, there were people who said Nowitzki would never get it done, and they were wrong.

But comparing one athlete to another provides proof of absolutely nothing. Luongo isn’t McNabb. He’s not Nowitzki either. He’s Luongo. And perhaps more importantly, the Canucks aren’t the Eagles or the Mavericks. Which is to say, “See? Nowitzki won a championship” is a feeble argument if you’re trying to convince someone the Canucks can win the Stanley Cup with Luongo in goal. (Not that Gallagher’s making that argument.)

It’s still interesting though, because it shows one of the main reasons we follow sports. Because we have no idea what’s coming next. Luongo had another rough outing last night in Edmonton. No word if he’ll start tonight versus the Blues. See? We have no idea!

PHT Morning Skate: General Managers around the league are happy for Bergevin

Marc Bergevin
Leave a comment

PHT’s Morning Skate takes a look around the world of hockey to see what’s happening and what we’ll be talking about around the NHL world and beyond.

The Montreal Canadiens gave Marc Bergevin a contract extension on Wednesday and fellow General Managers around the league are happy for their colleague. (TSN)

Are the Washington Capitals the best team in the Eastern Conference? (ESPN)

Here’s a funny cartoon depiction of the reported feud between Mario Lemieux and Sidney Crosby:

Read an excerpt from Tie Domi’s book “shift work”. In this portion of the book, he talks about some crazy times at a New York City nightclub. (ESPN)

“It’s a lot more complicated than the net and the goalie equipment, it’s the systems that teams play, the willingness of players to block shots every part of their body.” Steven Stamkos weighs in on the decreasing number of goals in the NHL. (Tampa Tribune)

After the first quarter of the season, Henrik Lundqvist is’s favorite to land the Vezina Trophy. (

Preds place Salomaki on IR, recall Sissons

Jake Allen, Miikka Salomaki
Leave a comment

Nashville made a minor roster transaction on Thursday, putting forward Miikka Salomaki on IR while recalling fellow forward Colton Sissons from AHL Milwaukee.

Salomaki, 22, was a fairly regular lineup presence through the of November, appearing in eight games while averaging just under 12 minutes per night. Despite his relatively small frame (5-foot-11, 198 pounds), he racked up 28 hits over that time and emerged as a decent energy guy for the Preds.

As for Sissons, he’s about to get yet another crack with the parent club.

Having spent most of the last two seasons in Milwaukee, Sissons — the 50th overall pick in 2012 — has seen some action with the Preds this year. He has one goal in five games with Nashville, and eight points in 12 games with the Admirals.

Oilers say McDavid ‘ahead of schedule’ in broken clavicle recovery

Connor McDavid
1 Comment

There hasn’t been much good news for the Oilers lately — Connor McDavid‘s hurt, Nail Yakupov‘s hurt, they’ve lost seven of their last nine — so what GM Peter Chiarelli had to say on Thursday qualified as very welcome news.

“He’s ahead of schedule,” Chiarelli said of Connor McDavid and his broken clavicle, per Sportsnet. “He’s been in the pool, been lifting weights… There are no soft tissue injuries, which is important.

“When you get a break like that, oftentimes there is accompanying soft tissue injuries. That slows down the recovery.”

McDavid, who suffered the injury on Nov. 3 against Philly, was originally supposed to be sidelined until early March. But per Sportsnet’s Mark Spector, there’s cautious optimism the star rookie could be back in the Edmonton lineup by “mid-to-late January.”

But even with that cautious optimism, there’s still a long way to go.

McDavid has yet to resume skating and is still at his parents’ home in Newmarket, Ontario. That said, he’s expected to join Edmonton soon — when the Oilers take on the Leafs in Toronto on Monday — and, according to Chiarelli, will want to get back onto the ice way sooner than expected.

“I can tell you that when it comes time,” he said, “[McDavid] is going to want to come back a lot earlier than what we forecast internally.”

There’s another Radulov NHL comeback rumor making the rounds

Leave a comment

It’s been roughly six months since the last one so yeah, time for an Alex Radulov update.

Radulov, who’s spent the last four seasons playing for KHL outfit CSKA Moscow, has reportedly rejected the club’s contract extension offer and is ready to become a free agent, per Russian sports writer Slava Malamud.

Sport-Express’ Igor Eronko also reported the Radulov news, tweeting the ex-Preds forward claimed “there’s nothing” regarding a new deal with CSKA, adding “I’m a free agent after this season.”

Radulov, 29, is having another terrific offensive campaign in Russia, with 37 points in 32 games. This comes one year after he tore up the KHL in ’14-15, with 24 goals and 71 points in just 46 contests — one of the best offensive campaigns in league history.

Rumors of Radulov returning to North America happen with the same frequency as Ilya Kovalchuk comeback rumblings, and always with the same outcome. But it’s hard to ignore them completely.


Well, back in late May, Radulov’s agent told Championat Colorado had been in contact about an NHL return once Radulov’s deal with CSKA expired. Colorado, of course, is coached by Patrick Roy — the same guy that had great success coaching Radulov in the QMJHL.

The two were, at one time, a dynamic force for the Quebec Remparts. During the 2005-06 campaign, Radulov scored a ridiculous 61 goals and 152 points in just 62 games, the nine more in four Memorial Cup contests, helping Roy capture his first and only championship as a head coach.

Radulov, of course, hasn’t played in the NHL since an ill-fated reunion with Nashville in 2012, which included him getting suspended for a playoff game after breaking curfew.

Malamud does note that, should Radulov try to return to the NHL, he’d do so as a unrestricted free agent — meaning he’s no longer Nashville property.