Taylor Fedun, Jordan Eberle

Hybrid or no-touch icing or bust: The NHL’s time for change is now


After Edmonton prospect Taylor Fedun broke his fibula taking a spill into the boards in a race for the puck with Minnesota’s Eric Nystrom, the tide of public opinion is changing. TSN’s Darren Dreger tweeted that it was time to change the methodology. His wasn’t the only opinion going that way either.

Our question here is: Why did it take seeing Fedun breaking his leg in a most grotesque way to change people’s minds on this?

I wrote here during RDO camp this summer how adding either no-touch or hybrid icing was a change that made a world of sense and that it wouldn’t change the fabric of the game. After seeing it used in college hockey last year, hybrid icing makes most sense for those coaches and GMs that fear losing “the race” aspect of icing will make the game “boring” if no-touch icing was the way to go.

Brian Burke supports hybrid or no-touch icing while guys like Edmonton’s own Steve Tambellini didn’t want to lose the speed aspect of the game. Perhaps seeing one of his own players have his season likely ended and his development put on hold for up to a year will change his mind. When something affects you directly your opinion can change fast.

Does it matter whether we see no-touch or hybrid icing though? Is having that race to the end boards worth having another freak accident or, worse yet, seeing a player’s malicious competitive edge come out to win a battle for the puck? Absolutely not.

After seeing Fedun’s injury last night and thinking back to Kurtis Foster, then of the Wild, having the same thing happen to him in a race for an icing call, it’s nonsensical to keep a race for the puck to get an icing call in the game. Icing is what it is and while it’s an important call in regard to where faceoffs occur and puck possession in the zone, it’s not so important we need to run the risk of players getting grossly injured to get the call.

Hockey is a rough and tumble sport as it is without adding this human NASCAR side-show to the festivities. Brendan Shanahan’s job as the head of player safety for the league has to be looking at what happened to Fedun and feeling sick about it. Changes to icing is something the league has looked at now for two years. The time for testing is over, the time for change is upon us.

Benn, Holtby and Galchenyuk are NHL’s three stars of the week

Cory Schneider, Alex Galchenyuk ,
Leave a comment

Stars winger Jamie Benn, Capitals goalie Braden Holtby and Canadiens center Alex Galchenyuk have been named the NHL’s three stars for the past week.

From NHL.com:

Benn shared the League lead in goals (4) and points (6) as the Stars (19-5-0, 38 points) won two of three games to continue their best start to a season in the franchise’s 48-year history.

Holtby posted a 4-0-0 record with a 1.75 goals-against average, .945 save percentage and one shutout to backstop the Capitals (17-5-1, 35 points) to the top of the Metropolitan Division standings.

Galchenyuk tied for first in the NHL with four goals and added one assist to help the Canadiens (18-4-3, 39 points) earn five of a possible six points and reclaim first place in the League standings.

As much as the injuries to Carey Price and Brendan Gallagher have been frustrating for the Canadiens, those are short-term issues that should be forgotten soon enough. Galchenyuk’s play, in contrast, is reason for long-term optimism. The 21-year-old is trending towards becoming the elite No. 1 center the Habs have needed so badly. He’s not there yet, but when’s all said and done, he could turn out to be the best forward (or player, period) taken in the 2012 draft.

Stepan to miss 4-6 weeks with broken ribs


Derek Stepan is out 4-6 weeks with broken ribs, the New York Rangers announced today.

Stepan was hurt Friday on a controversial hit by Boston’s Matt Beleskey. The Bruins’ forward did not receive any supplemental discipline for the check, despite admitting it was “maybe…a little bit late.”

At any rate it’s a big loss for the Rangers, who suddenly find themselves on a three-game losing streak. Considering the timeline, New York could be without one of its top centers for 12-18 games, give or take.

The Rangers host Carolina tonight.

Related: Yep, Alain Vigneault went there — ‘I remember Aaron Rome in this building’

Price to miss minimum six weeks, so no Winter Classic for him

Carey Price,
1 Comment

Carey Price will miss a minimum of six weeks with a lower-body injury, the Montreal Canadiens announced today.

That means Price will miss the Winter Classic against the Bruins on New Year’s Day. The 28-year-old goalie has only appeared in 12 games this season.

On the bright side, the reigning Hart Trophy winner will not require surgery. And considering the Habs have already built up a 13-point playoff cushion in the standings, well, if something like this were going to happen during the season, now is as good a time as any.

Related: The latest on Price’s injury

Report: Jets offered Byfuglien for Hamonic, Isles said no

Dustin Byfuglien

If Travis Hamonic could choose one team to be traded to, he’d probably choose Winnipeg. The 25-year-old Islanders defenseman wants to be closer to his family, and his family is from Manitoba. Hamonic already owns a condo in Winnipeg.

So far, though, the Jets and Islanders haven’t been able to work out a deal. The Jets have three right-shot defensemen in Dustin Byfuglien, Jacob Trouba, and Tyler Myers who could, theoretically, be swapped for Hamonic, also a right shot.

“I think the Islanders were offered Byfuglien and they said no,” Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman said this morning on Sportsnet 960 (audio), per Today’s Slapshot. “And I understand why, because Byfuglien’s got no term left.

“I think they’d love to have Trouba, but the Jets aren’t really there to do it. Myers, if it’s happened – I can’t say for sure it has or hasn’t – I’m not sure that’s the deal either team really wants to make, to be perfectly honest.”

Byfuglien is a pending unrestricted free agent who’s expected to cash in big-time on his next deal. The 30-year-old may not be the most disciplined player, but at his best, he’s an absolute force on the back end.

That the Isles reportedly said no to Byfuglien shouldn’t really come as a surprise, given his contract uncertainty. However, it does make one wonder about his future in Winnipeg. Remember that the salary cap is not expected to go up by much, and the Jets have another pending UFA in captain Andrew Ladd, plus a couple of key RFAs in Trouba and Mark Scheifele.

While it’s never easy to tell what GM Kevin Cheveldayoff is thinking, the big question with Byfuglien and the Jets may end up being when, not if, they part ways. Will it be after the season or before the Feb. 29 trade deadline?