PHT makes the case for the Selke Trophy finalists

2 Comments

The Frank J. Selke Trophy might be one of the most subjective awards in all of sports. By definition, the Selke goes to the NHL forward who “demonstrates the most skill in the defensive component of the game.” Unofficially, the award goes to the best all-around forward in the NHL. There’s a reason that all three finalists are also amazing offensive talents. The three finalists this season should know their way to The Palms in Las Vegas—because they were all nominated last year as well.

Here are PHT’s best arguments for each of the three finalists to win the coveted award.

Matt Reitz’s case for Ryan Kesler:

The award for best defensive forward oftentimes goes to a great player who happens to play well on the defensive side of the puck. Both Pavel Datsyuk and Jonathan Toews had good seasons—but neither were on the same level as Kesler. And let’s be honest, it’s hard to give any award to Datsyuk because he missed 26 games.

Ryan Kesler actually fits into both roles—he’s a great player who happens to also be great defensively. He’s had a great all-around season and is an extremely good defensive player. His 57.4% faceoff percentage was tied for 6th in the league; and he won more faceoffs than anyone else in the league NOT named Jonathan Toews. He was in the top 10 with 3 shorthanded goals while killing penalties and served as the teams emotional leader as he lead all Vancouver forwards in blocked shots and takeaways (and was fourth in hits). Not bad when you consider Manny Malhotra plays on the same team. Oh, and he dropped 41 goals to finish in a tie for 4th in the league. That helps get a little attention.

Joe Yerdon’s case for Pavel Datsyuk:

Well really, what isn’t there to like about Pavel Datsyuk? You want a center who can defend and score and he can do that. He had 71 takeaways during the season. That total was good for 11th in the NHL. Sure that doesn’t seem impressive until you realize he missed 26 games this season. He won 54.6% of his faceoffs and also scored 23 goals with 36 assists.

He can defend against your best forwards and score against your best defenders. He’s a threat to steal the puck away anytime he’s on  the ice and he’s been lauded for his defensive work already in the past winning the Selke Trophy the last three years in a row. Ryan Kesler might’ve had a great year, but he’s still wearing Pavel Datsyuk underpants each day when it comes to playing defense.

James O’Brien’s case for Jonathan Toews:

I agree with Matt regarding Datsyuk; missing 26 games eliminates him despite his greatness. While Kesler is a great candidate, both players seem to follow an interesting pattern in that they probably weren’t the best defensive centers on their teams (Kesler had Manny Malhotra; Toews had Dave Bolland) but dazzled as two-way players.

Ultimately, I think Toews deserves the Selke because a greater burden was put on his shoulders. The Vancouver Canucks shared the wealth at center (Henrik Sedin was counted upon more for scoring while Malhotra took plenty of draws in his own zone) while the Chicago Blackhawks counted on Toews to be Mr. Everything. (Again, Bolland helped, but Toews was often on an island.)

Toews won the second most faceoffs in the league. He came in second in the NHL in takeaways with 93 to Kesler’s 65 and Datsyuk’s 71 (it’s a nebulous category, but people usually love to cite it when choosing Datsyuk). The hockey world is still refining its methods of measuring great defensive play, so in the mean time, go with the guy who’s doing the most at each end of the ice. Toews fits that bill in 2010-11.

Bruins without Bergeron vs. Leafs in Game 4

Leave a comment

The Boston Bruins rolled through much of the regular season despite injuries, even to key players like Patrice Bergeron. The fact that they’re unfortunately experienced playing without Bergeron is probably the only silver lining regarding his late scratch heading into Game 4.

The Bruins announced that Bergeron is day-to-day with what they’re deeming an upper-body injury, so Riley Nash slips into Bergeron’s spot between Brad Marchand and David Pastrnak.

This stands as an obvious opportunity for Auston Matthews to roam more freely against the Bruins and a chance for the Maple Leafs to tie this series in front of their home fans.

As of this writing, the two teams are tied up 1-1. Click here for the livestream link.

Doughty, Hedman, Subban are 2018 Norris Trophy finalists

3 Comments

Drew Doughty of the Los Angeles Kings, Victor Hedman of the Tampa Bay Lightning and P.K. Subban of the Nashville Predators have been named finalists for the 2018 Norris Trophy. The award, voted on by the Professional Hockey Writers Assocation, is given “to the defense player who demonstrates throughout the season the greatest all-round ability in the position,” will be handed out during the NHL Awards show June 20 in Las Vegas.

This is the fourth time Doughty has been name a finalist. He won the award in 2016 after finishing second the year before. Hedman finished third in the voting last season and this is the second time he’s finished in the top three. Subban, like Doughty, has a Norris Trophy on his resume (2013). This is the third time he’s been up for the award.

[NBC’s Stanley Cup Playoff Hub]

The Case for Drew Doughty: The Kings blue liner finished sixth in scoring among defensemen with 60 points, which included 10 goals. He also led all NHL players in total ice time with 2,200:31, finishing with an average of 26:50 per game. He had a strong possession game with a 53 percent Corsi and a 4.39 Relative Corsi, meaning LA fired nearly five shots more per 60 minutes when Doughty was on the ice.

“I’m not starting the season, thinking ‘oh I got to get the most points I can, so I can win the Norris,’” he told The Athletic last month. “I’m starting the season, thinking, ‘I’ve got to get my defensive game even better, because that’s where my team needs me the most – to lead the charge in that area. It’s a team game and it’s about winning championships.”

The Case for Victor Hedman: Hedman finished tied for first among defensemen in goals scored with 17 and finished fourth in points with 63. He set a career high in ice time with 1,990:30 total minutes, averaging 25:51 per night. The possession stats for the Lightning defenseman were solid as well, with a 52 percent Corsi and a 0.38 Relative Corsi.

“I’m fortunate to be on an unbelievable team that helped me out through my first decade in the league, to help me grow into the player I want to be,” he told Sports Illustrated in February. “Still got stuff to work on and get better at, but obviously winning the Norris would be something that I want to do. I want to be at the top of my game. I want to play my best every night.”

The Case for P.K. Subban: Subban was right behind Hedman in goals scored (16) and right behind Doughty in total points (59). He logged 1,977:24 of ice time, playing in all 82 games for the Predators this season. As you’d expect from a Norris finalist, his possession stats were good, as he finished with a 52 percent Corsi and a 0.3 Relative Corsi.

Earlier this season, Subban told the Tennessean he felt his defensive game was overlooked. “The offensive part of my game has always been there,” he said. “The defensive part has always been there as well, but for whatever reason, I don’t seem to get the credit for what I do in my (defensive) zone and how I contribute defensively for our hockey club.”

2018 NHL Award finalists
Lady Byng (Friday)
Selke Trophy
Vezina Trophy

————

Sean Leahy is a writer for Pro Hockey Talk on NBC Sports. Drop him a line at phtblog@nbcsports.com or follow him on Twitter @Sean_Leahy.

WATCH LIVE: Leafs, Blue Jackets try to even things up

Getty Images
2 Comments

Game 4: Boston Bruins at Toronto Maple Leafs, 7 p.m. ET (Bruins lead series 2-1)
NBCSN
Call: Mike Emrick, Pierre McGuire, Eddie Olczyk
Series preview
Stream

Game 4: Washington Capitals at Columbus Blue Jackets, 7:30 p.m. ET (Blue Jackets lead 2-1)
USA
Call: Ken Daniels, Darren Pang
Series preview
Stream

[NBC’s Stanley Cup Playoff Hub]

Predators’ Ryan Hartman suspended one game for illegal check to head

Getty
2 Comments

When the Nashville Predators attempt to close out their series against the Colorado Avalanche on Friday night they will be without forward Ryan Hartman.

The NHL’s Department of Player Safety announced on Thursday afternoon that Hartman has been suspended one game for an illegal check to the head of Avalanche forward Carl Soderberg during the Predators’ 3-2 win in Game 4 on Wednesday.

Here is the NHL’s explanation for the suspension.

He was given a two-minute minor penalty for charging on the play. It happened early in the third period.

It turned out to be a pretty eventful night for Hartman as he was also penalized in the second period for roughing and holding the stick during a sequence that saw him get speared by Avalanche forward Sven Andrighetto.

Andrighetto was given a roughing penalty during the sequence, but to this point has not received any supplemental discipline for the spearing incident.

[NBC’s Stanley Cup Playoff Hub]

This is already the fourth suspension of the playoffs as Hartman joins Drew Doughty (one game), Nazem Kadri (three games), and Josh Morrissey (one game) as players to sit for at least one game.

There was only one suspension during the entire 2017 playoffs.

The Predators acquired Hartman at the trade deadline from the Chicago Blackhawks in exchange for Victor Ejdsell, a first-round pick, and a fourth-round pick. In 78 games this season between the two teams he scored 11 goals to go with 20 assists. Three of those goals game as a member of the Predators. So far in the first-round series against Colorado he has scored one goal for the Predators.

Related: Avalanche to start Andrew Hammond in Game 5

————

Adam Gretz is a writer for Pro Hockey Talk on NBC Sports. Drop him a line at phtblog@nbcsports.com or follow him on Twitter @AGretz.