The case for Sidney Crosby for the Hart Trophy

Crosby2.jpgAs we near the end of the season, we’re going to take a look at
who we think should be three finalists for the Hart, Norris and Calder
Trophies, making arguments for each. We start with the Hart
Trophy, given to the NHL’s Most Valuable Player. Next up: Sidney
Crosby.

Why he deserves it: The player many
(well, perhaps half of you) consider the best player in the NHL is in
the midst of the best season of his career after finding that putting
the puck on net more will result in more goals. Imagine that. He’s
leading the NHL with 49 goals and is third in the league with 104 points
and with the Pittsburgh Penguins fighting through injuries has become
more vital to his team than ever before. Last season Crosby showed us
just how great a playmaker he is; this season we’re learning that he is
one hell of a goal scorer as well. As if we didn’t already know it, but
this season he’s hammered the point home.

Why he doesn’t
deserve it:
I originally wasn’t going to list Crosby as a
finalist, since I wanted just three for each trophy. But I figured that
including Ovechkin and not having Crosby in the discussion would be
near-blasphemy. All the same, I’m not certain that Crosby deserves the
Hart as much as Ryan Miller or Henrik Sedin. He’s not as dominant night
after night as they are, and with the Penguins struggling with
consistency lately it’s tough to pinpoint exactly how much the impact of
their struggles will hurt him. What will certainly play against Crosby
is his plus-13, significantly dwarfed by the incredible number put up by
Ovechking and Sedin.

Why he’ll get it: Crosby is
still evolving as a hockey player and this season he showed that he can
certainly take a step in a new direction do what is needed to help his
team succeed. He’s the captain of the Stanley Cup defending Penguins,
and there’s a good chance he finishes with the most goals in the NHL.

Why
he won’t get it:
Simply because no matter how great a season
he’s had, it hasn’t been anywhere near as great or impressive as the
others’. The way he’s struggled to score with Evgeni Malkin in the
lineup might also play against him.

Scroll Down For:

    Malcolm Subban in stable condition, suffered fractured larynx

    malcolmsubbangetty
    Getty
    Leave a comment

    The Boston Bruins updated Malcolm Subban‘s condition a day after the goaltending prospect was hospitalized after being struck in the throat with a puck.

    “Malcolm Subban was struck in the throat with a puck Saturday night during pregame warmups. He was transported to Maine Medical Center and was diagnosed with a fractured larynx. He stayed overnight at Maine Medical Center and was transported to Mass General Hospital on Sunday for further evaluation. He is in stable condition and will be sidelined indefinitely. The team will provide additional details when they become available.”

    Awful news, although at least he’s in stable condition.

    PHT will stay tuned for further updates regarding the 22-year-old.

    Subban did tweet a thanks for support:

    A little context makes that a little sad, too.

    Fight video: Zack Kassian racks up penalty minutes, faces Brian Strait

    Leave a comment

    Pulling Anders Nilsson didn’t stop the bleeding for the Edmonton Oilers. Instead, it really just spread the “wealth.”

    The New York Islanders are up 7-1, so don’t be surprised if there’s some ugly stuff in the final frame.

    Zack Kassian is an author of at least one outburst, as he was tagged with 19 penalty minutes for a display that included fighting Brian Strait, as you can see in the video above.

    It’s not the only fight stemming from the blowout, either, as Eric Gryba just tangled with Matt Martin.

    Could there be more?

    Isles chase Nilsson from Oilers’ net in less than 12 minutes

    Edmonton Oilers goalie Anders Nilsson, of Sweden, makes pad save against the Colorado Avalanche during the first period of an NHL hockey game Saturday, Dec. 19, 2015, in Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski)
    AP
    5 Comments

    There was a time when Anders Nilsson seemed like the best bet in the Oilers’ net this season. This … is not that time.

    Less than 12 minutes into Sunday’s game, the New York Islanders roared to a 3-0 lead, and that was enough for Edmonton to give Nilsson the hook.

    He allowed those three goals on 10 shots, so to be fair, that’s a pretty impressive chunk of chances (almost a shot on goal per minute).

    Still, the Oilers were likely hoping to give Cam Talbot a breather, and instead he was rushed into action. Nilsson hadn’t played since Jan. 19, and he’s only appeared in three games in 2016.

    As if this didn’t sting enough for Nilsson, consider the fact that he began his NHL career with the Islanders, who eventually decided he wasn’t worth keeping.

    Ovi scores 30th as Caps beat Flyers for third straight victory

    2 Comments

    Alex Ovechkin scored to join Wayne Gretzky and Mike Gartner as only players with at least 30 goals in each of their first 11 NHL seasons, and Matt Niskanen netted the game winner as Washington beat the Flyers 3-2 at Verizon on Super Bowl Sunday.

    Michael Del Zotto and Nick Schultz replied for the Flyers, who suffered their second straight loss.

    The win was the Capitals’ third in a row.

    It didn’t always look as though Washington would emerge the victor, however. The Caps were out-shot 35-30 on the day and looked disjointed at times, finishing with 12 giveaways (Philly was credited with just five, for comparison’s sake).

    But good teams find ways to win when they’re not playing especially well, and the Caps are a pretty good team — especially when Braden Holtby is on his game.

    Holtby, atop many Vezina lists at the moment, had another terrific outing on Sunday, making 33 saves, perhaps none better than this one on Mark Streit in the second period:

    Holtby’s counterpart, Steve Mason, had a solid outing as well, finishing with 27 stops.

    Looking ahead, the Caps will now head out on a three-game Western Conference swing through Minnesota, Nashville and what promises to be a high-octane game in Dallas on Feb. 13.

    The Flyers, meanwhile, will now kick off a three-game homestand against Anaheim, Buffalo and New Jersey.